Fashion

Manyavar parent SSSG grows 47% over FY20

Louis Vuitton creates Insta filter for collaboration with ace designer

Merc Maybach S680 – first car bought by a Retail Entrepreneur

ABFRL strengthens TMRW with grand scale plans and D2C acquisitions

Garnier Opens Plastic Waste Collection Center – to Integrate Ocean-bound Plastic into Packaging

Retailers report steep drop in Sales after Deepavali

E-Commerce

Flipkart spent Rs. 15,020 Cr to earn Rs. 10,476 Cr in revenues
E-Commerce

Flipkart spent Rs. 15,020 Cr to earn Rs. 10,476 Cr in revenues

December 15, 2022
Big Basket spent Rs. 1.10 to earn Re. 1 in FY 21-22; Losses climb 4x
E-Commerce

Big Basket spent Rs. 1.10 to earn Re. 1 in FY 21-22; Losses climb 4x

October 11, 2022
Victoria’s Secret onboards Amazon

Victoria’s Secret onboards Amazon

June 25, 2022
Vinod launches 100% Virgin Aluminium Cookware
Indian Ecomm

Vinod launches 100% Virgin Aluminium Cookware

January 21, 2022
Friday, February 3, 2023
  • Login
Retail Updates
No Result
View All Result
  • FMCG
    • FMCG Food
      • Indian FMCG – Food
      • Regional FMCG – Food
      • StartUps FMCG – Food
      • International FMCG – Food
    • FMCG Non-Food
      • Indian FMCG Non-Food
      • Regional FMCG Non-Food
      • Startups FMCG Non-Food
      • International FMCG Non-Food
  • Fashion
    • Luxury
    • Womens’
    • Menswear
    • Kidswear
    • Innerwear
    • Accessories
      • Cosmetics
      • Eyewear
      • Footwear
      • Leather
      • Personal Care
      • Watches
      • Wearables
  • F&B
    • QSR
    • Traditional
    • Cloud Kitchens
  • E-Commerce
    • Amazon
    • Indian Ecomm
    • Services
  • Malls
    • Mall Chains
    • Standalone Malls
  • International
    • USA
    • Singapore
    • China
    • Middle East
    • SE Asia
    • Europe
    • Oz & Nz
    • SouthAm
  • Specialty Retail
    • Travel Retail
      • Airports
      • Metro Rail
      • Railways
      • Highways
    • Auto Retail
      • 2W
      • 4W
      • EVs
      • Fuel Retail
    • Liquor
    • Salons
    • CDIT
    • Grocery Retail
    • Home Improvement
  • Entertainment
    • Cinemas
    • Multiplex
    • OTT Platforms
    • Theme Parks
    • Others
  • Retail Tech
    • Digital
    • Retail AI
    • PoS S/w
    • Payments
    • Credit Cards
    • Crypto
    • Tech Delivery
  • Cities
  • Corporates
    • Industry Info
    • Global
      • Apple
      • Nestle
      • Walmart
      • Starbucks
      • Shell
    • Indian
      • Aditya Birla
      • Arvind Fashions
      • Future Group
      • Reliance
      • Tata Group
      • Shoppers Stop
      • ITC
      • HUL
      • Marico
      • Britannia
      • Dabur
      • Patanjali
      • Reckitt
      • Colgate
    • Listed Cos.
  • Opinions
    • Blogs
    • Videos
    • Interviews
    • Lockdown Impact
    • Editor’s Note
Retail Updates
Enforcing Uniform Price Mechanism by Franchisees – Governance or Anti-Competitive?

Enforcing Uniform Price Mechanism by Franchisees – Governance or Anti-Competitive?

by Editor
August 23, 2021
in Industry Info, Opinions
Reading Time: 4 mins read
0

In a stunning move by the CCI – Competition Commission of India, the governing body which oversees various types of anti-competitive actions taken by various companies and corporates, imposed a fine of Rs. 200 Crores on Maruti Suzuki India Ltd., India’s largest automobile maker by volumes, for limiting the quantum of discounts offered by its dealers to end-user customers. It was found by CCI to be in contravention of the provisions of Section 3(4)(e) read with Section 3(1) of the Competition Act, 2002, in what is said to be a landmark judgement in the consumer retail business. Reacting to the CCI order, Maruti Suzuki said: “We have seen the order dated 23 August 2021 published by the CCI. We are examining the order and will take appropriate actions under the law. The MSIL has always worked in the best interests of consumers and will continue to do so in the future.”

According to an anonymous complaint received by the autonomous body in 2019 purportedly by a dealer of the company, the dealer network of the company were restricted by the Principal (MSIL) not to offer additional discounts than what was provided for and already approved by the Company. For passing additional benefits to car buyers, such as accessories or cash discounts, the Dealer had to get an explicit written approval from the Company failing which penalties were imposed, including suspension of supplies. The Dealers, according to allegations, were constantly being monitored through “Mystery Shopping Agencies”, who reported malpractices and deviations to the Principal with audio and video evidences such as an audio transcipt or videos of such engagement by the staff of the Dealers. In other words, the company has a “Discount Control Policy” indulging in anti-competitive conduct of “Resale Price Maintenance” according to CCI. This was adjudged anti-competitive since the “trader” was not allowed to operate their business according to their own wishes & convenience and was strictly enforced in cities and towns where there were more than 5 dealers.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

Retail stores hit an early Diwali; Shoppers crowd markets and malls alike

Air travel demand – a reflection of Economy?

While restricting competitiveness in any business is condemnable, what is stunning in this verdict especially, is how the SOPs – standard operating procedures of a Principal which is in the business of Retailing of products, have been interpreted by the law enforcing agency. This could have some serious repurcussion in the USD 850 Bn Retail Industry in India, where thousands of brands have franchised their business operations to lakhs of Franchisee Partners (Dealerships in case of the Automobile Industry). International brands like Levis, Benetton, Adidas and many more entered India through the single brand FDI route in the 90s and operated their retail business through Franchises. While in most cases, the MRP – Maximum Retail Price is fixed, as per the MRP Act of India, the consumer and the retailer mutually decide on the final price of the transaction. In fact, several categories of products, especially in CDIT, such as Flat panel TVs, Laptops, Washing Machines and even Mobile phones do not have a MRP regime for several years now, rather the retailer decides on the selling price (to the consumer) almost on a case to case basis. Brands like Apple, through their distribution network have a strict Price regime, which means that Authorised Resellers cannot offer additional discounts to customers, which includes add-ons or accessories. This is their way of controlling the competitiveness among the distribution partners.

In case of apparel, which is the most franchised format among all consumer goods, there is no such gag-order by the principals, though the Franchise Partners maintain best case pricing and offer no more than a 10% discount to preferred customers on a need basis. In case of F&B brands such as Subway or Rajdhani, the Franchise Partner is mostly at will to offer add-on to loyal customers, though professing such offers through mass media or social media are restricted by the parent brand / company.

In the uber-competitive automobile industry, hungry-for-discount customers bargain a lot across brands as well as within the Dealer network of a Brand. In most cases, the final decision to buy a model or a brand is solely dependent on the soft corner the buyer develops with a particular dealer, save for those who do not have such a choice in smaller towns, unfortunately. However, the Dealers try to appease the appetite of customers as much as they can, though they are strictly governed by the regulations imposed by their Principals. The order by CCI in this case is not just misleading for the entire Franchising Industry but can also cause enormous confusion to customers as well, as they may demand preferential and differential treatment across various outlets which sell the same brand, which are run by Franchisees.

The Industry has been quite well self-governed and it is in the best interest of all partners in the ecosystem – the Manufacturer, the Operator (Franchisee / Dealer) and the Customer to decide on the best pricing option, of course without causing an adverse impact for the buyer. This case could be very interesting to watch for the consumer retail industry, how MSIL would respond and thereafter, how other OEMs – Original Equipment Manufacturers would react to the situation. And of course, Manufacturers and Brand Owners across the segment from F&B to Tyres, Apparel to Ice Cream Parlours and so on. With a growing fondness of the Indian consumer diaspora by internationally acclaimed brands, such rulings may have an adverse impact when global brands decide to enter and operate in India through a Franchise network.

We shall keep writing on this case in times to come.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Telegram (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Skype (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

ShareTweetShare

Related Posts

Retail stores hit an early Diwali; Shoppers crowd markets and malls alike
Industry Info

Retail stores hit an early Diwali; Shoppers crowd markets and malls alike

October 31, 2022
Air travel demand – a reflection of Economy?
Opinions

Air travel demand – a reflection of Economy?

October 11, 2022
Retail Horoscope for May 2022
Industry Info

Retail Horoscope for May 2022

June 25, 2022
Fashion Retail sizzles amidst looming 4th wave of Covid
Industry Info

Fashion Retail sizzles amidst looming 4th wave of Covid

June 25, 2022
LuLu Group to play LaLaLa in Tamil Nadu
Industry Info

All is well, says Retailer‘s body; 12% growth over 2019 levels

May 1, 2022

Listed Companies

PVR Cinemas admits reduce in Q3 compared with 2019
Entertainment

PVR Cinemas admits reduce in Q3 compared with 2019

by Editor
January 20, 2023
0

PVR Cinemas, India's largest multiplex chain had 1.78 lakh seats across 821 screens in India during the 9 months of...

Read more
Back to work impact – Metro Shoes reports highest ever revenues in Q1 FY23

Back to work impact – Metro Shoes reports highest ever revenues in Q1 FY23

October 11, 2022
Reliance Retail posts best-ever performance in Q1 FY2223, more to come

Reliance Retail posts best-ever performance in Q1 FY2223, more to come

August 14, 2022
Titan Industries grows 36% yoy | Tanishq Jewelry by 37% over FY 20-21

Titan Industries grows 36% yoy | Tanishq Jewelry by 37% over FY 20-21

March 6, 2022
Dominos India now at 1,500 locations – Revenues up 13%

Dominos India now at 1,500 locations – Revenues up 13%

March 6, 2022

FMCG

Quick Commerce – End of the Road?

Flipkart spent Rs. 15,020 Cr to earn Rs. 10,476 Cr in revenues

Big Basket spent Rs. 1.10 to earn Re. 1 in FY 21-22; Losses climb 4x

Daawat celebrates World Biriyani Day

Retail Horoscope for May 2022

Metro Cash & Carry expands frontiers in home turf Karnataka

Cities

Tamil Nadu allows Retailers to operate 24/7
Cities

Tamil Nadu allows Retailers to operate 24/7

by Editor
July 3, 2022
0

Tamil Nadu Government allows Retailers to operate 24/7, 365 days a year. Move to boost festival sales especially; retailers ecstatic...

Read more
LuLu Group to play LaLaLa in Tamil Nadu

LuLu Group to play LaLaLa in Tamil Nadu

May 1, 2022
Sunday Lockdown in TN may go – if cases reduce: Minister

Sunday Lockdown in TN may go – if cases reduce: Minister

March 6, 2022
KA State relaxes Weekend Lockdown; Shops, Restaurants to remain open

KA State relaxes Weekend Lockdown; Shops, Restaurants to remain open

January 21, 2022
D’Mart Earnings surge 106% for Q3, 105% for H1

D’Mart Q3 shows rural economy is bouncing back

January 12, 2022

Who We are…

Retail Updates strives it’s best to curate the latest in the world of Retailing from across the world and offers insights and analyses.

No Result
View All Result

In case you missed…

  • Manyavar parent SSSG grows 47% over FY20
  • PVR opens at Chennai Airport
  • Reliance Retail reports Rs. 67,000 Cr Q3 revenues

Search by Tags

E-Commerce F&B Fashion FMCG Industry Info Latest News Listed Cos. Lockdown Impact QSR
  • FMCG
    • FMCG Food
      • Indian FMCG – Food
      • Regional FMCG – Food
      • StartUps FMCG – Food
      • International FMCG – Food
    • FMCG Non-Food
      • Indian FMCG Non-Food
      • Regional FMCG Non-Food
      • Startups FMCG Non-Food
      • International FMCG Non-Food
  • Fashion
    • Luxury
    • Womens’
    • Menswear
    • Kidswear
    • Innerwear
    • Accessories
      • Cosmetics
      • Eyewear
      • Footwear
      • Leather
      • Personal Care
      • Watches
      • Wearables
  • F&B
    • QSR
    • Traditional
    • Cloud Kitchens
  • E-Commerce
    • Amazon
    • Indian Ecomm
    • Services
  • Malls
    • Mall Chains
    • Standalone Malls
  • International
    • USA
    • Singapore
    • China
    • Middle East
    • SE Asia
    • Europe
    • Oz & Nz
    • SouthAm
  • Specialty Retail
    • Travel Retail
      • Airports
      • Metro Rail
      • Railways
      • Highways
    • Auto Retail
      • 2W
      • 4W
      • EVs
      • Fuel Retail
    • Liquor
    • Salons
    • CDIT
    • Grocery Retail
    • Home Improvement
  • Entertainment
    • Cinemas
    • Multiplex
    • OTT Platforms
    • Theme Parks
    • Others
  • Retail Tech
    • Digital
    • Retail AI
    • PoS S/w
    • Payments
    • Credit Cards
    • Crypto
    • Tech Delivery
  • Cities
  • Corporates
    • Industry Info
    • Global
      • Apple
      • Nestle
      • Walmart
      • Starbucks
      • Shell
    • Indian
      • Aditya Birla
      • Arvind Fashions
      • Future Group
      • Reliance
      • Tata Group
      • Shoppers Stop
      • ITC
      • HUL
      • Marico
      • Britannia
      • Dabur
      • Patanjali
      • Reckitt
      • Colgate
    • Listed Cos.
  • Opinions
    • Blogs
    • Videos
    • Interviews
    • Lockdown Impact
    • Editor’s Note

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d bloggers like this: